Work

Evaluation of Standard Machine Learning for Plant Leaf Disease Recognition on a Small Field Image Dataset

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Most image-based plant disease studies train deep networks on large laboratory datasets, yet many practical projects have only a few hundred field photographs and no GPU. This paper evaluates eight standard machine learning classifiers on a small field image dataset of 1,532 leaf photographs labelled Healthy, Powdery (powdery mildew) and Rust, using 129 hand-crafted colour, texture and shape features. Classifiers were compared by nested, repeated stratified cross-validation on the 1,382 training and validation images, and the best model was tested once on the untouched official 150-image test set. Gradient boosting achieved the highest cross-validated accuracy (92.04% ± 1.41%) and significantly outperformed random forest (89.87%; corrected resampled t-test, p = 0.021). On the official test set it reached 89.33% accuracy (95% CI 83.4–93.3%), a macro F1-score of 89.37% and Cohen's κ = 0.84, within four points of a published DenseNet121 result on the same data. Colour and texture features were the most informative; adding shape features reduced k-nearest-neighbour accuracy from 87.37% to 66.79%. Random forest was the most data-efficient model, reaching 68.4% test accuracy with only five training images per class. The commonest error was a diseased leaf predicted as healthy (10 of 100 diseased test leaves). A bias control using only eight border pixels per image reached 58.1% in cross-validation but 38.7% on the test set (chance: 33.3%), revealing that capture conditions shared within the training split inflate cross-validated estimates. Classical machine learning is therefore a strong, low-cost baseline for field disease recognition, provided performance is reported on an independent test set.
Language: English
Subfield: Plant Science
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226012790
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10