Work

Truthfulness, Privacy, and the Regulation of Relational Access

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: : This article examines how a person can remain truthful while regulating access to personal information. It distinguishes truthfulness, which governs the relation between what a person asserts and what that person takes to be true, from total transparency, which concerns how accessible information is to others. It also distinguishes privacy, understood as the legitimate regulation of access, from deceptive concealment. Drawing on the philosophy of Finite Continuance, the article treats disclosure as a constitutive exchange: information changes what others can expect, demand, and decide, and so redistributes power and shapes future agency. A legitimate demand for information requires an adequate ground, a proportionate scope, and a relation to the rights or decisions of the person making it. Where no such ground exists, a person retains presumptive authority over the information in question. That authority is bounded by two duties: to correct materially misleading impressions, and to disclose facts that another person needs for an informed choice. The article further analyzes how repeated demands for explanation can harden into sedimented expectations that gradually erode the capacity to revise relationships and futures. Four concepts structure the account: reconfigurative capacity, the Dynamic Mask, Responsible Suspension, and the Threshold of Sufficiency. The article argues that truthfulness and privacy can coexist within an ethics of finite coexistence, provided that disclosure, refusal, and silence remain proportionate, accountable, and revisable. The inquiry is conceptual rather than empirical. Its aim is to supply a framework for assessing particular cases of disclosure and nondisclosure, not to offer a clinical instrument or to claim empirical validation for its models. Keywords: truthfulness; disclosure; privacy; silence; Finite Continuance; reconfigurative capacity; Dynamic Mask; Responsible Suspension; entitlement; relational ethics
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226018009
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10