Work

Are Europe's cities too small? a Europe-USA comparison of the role of urban size in productivity and growth

Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: Europe's per capita income has fallen markedly behind that of the United States since the mid-2000s. This paper examines one overlooked dimension of the gap: the structure of urban systems. Using harmonized OECD data on Functional Urban Areas (FUAs) for 162 US and nearly 300 EU+UK urban areas over 2002-2023, we show that the US urban system follows Zipf's law (rank-size slope of -1.0). The European system is significantly flatter (-0.8). Europe lacks a group of large, highly productive second-rank metropolitan areas, which harbor over a quarter of US output. Productivity rises with city size on both continents, with pooled elasticities of about 0.10 in the US and 0.08 in Europe. At any given size, however, US cities are 15-25% more productive, and the gap widens above 5 million inhabitants, which comprises most of the numerous second tier cites in the US system. The US also allocates a much larger share of employment to its most productive cities (62% versus 36% in the top 50 productive FUAs). A simple compositional counterfactual suggests that adopting the US allocation would raise EU+UK GDP by about 11%. Moreover, while in 2008 the two FUA productivity distributions were similar, by 2021, they had diverged considerably. The US distribution shifted uniformly to the right, while the European distribution stagnated outside its converging lower tail. allocation gap is persistent, and so could help explain Europe's productivity deficit, it does not explain the post-2008 widening. Patent data point to larger and more frontier-oriented innovation hubs in US second-tier cities, a possible source of their unusually high contribution to US urban productivity. The purpose of this paper is to encourage further attention to the role of spatial structure in European economic performance.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226037027
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10