Year: 2026
Type: book
Abstract: Health systems across countries combine public and private providers that often compete for publicly funded patients. Economic theory predicts that private providers may face stronger incentives to operate more efficiently. We test this hypothesis by estimating the causal effect of hospital ownership on length of stay (LOS), a common indicator of hospital efficiency. To account for unobserved patient heterogeneity, we instrument hospital ownership with differential distance to the nearest public and private provider. Estimation is conducted using a two-part model within a two-stage residual inclusion framework. In the first part, we use a probit model to estimate the probability of an overnight stay. In the second part, we use a negative binomial model for inpatient LOS. This specification allows us to distinguish differences in provider behaviour in overnight admission decisions from differences in the management of inpatient stays. We analyse administrative data on 596,852 publicly funded admissions for planned surgical procedures in orthopaedics, general surgery, and gynaecology in England between April 2023 and March 2024. The instrumental variable estimates indicate that private providers have lower inpatient LOS by approximately 0.58 days. By contrast, we find no significant effect of hospital ownership on the probability of an overnight stay. Private providers also exhibit lower 30-day emergency readmissions, by 0.37 percentage points under the instrumental variable approach. Separating day-case and inpatient processes is therefore important for understanding how ownership shapes provider behaviour across related margins of care. Our findings suggest that private-sector participation in elective care could improve efficiency without compromising quality. CHE Discussion Papers (DPs) began publication in 1983 as a means of making current research material more widely available to health economists and other potential users. The CHE Research Paper series takes over that function and provides access to current research output via web-based publication. The RPs can take various forms and results and ideas do not necessarily represent the final position and may include work in progress not subject to peer review at the time of publication. CHE RP 204 is an early version of a research paper currently under review at an academic journal.
Institution: University of York
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226037716
