Work

Why Pairwise Force Fields Can Reproduce Ionic Conductivity but Not Solvation Shells

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Pairwise force fields with scaled ionic charges are routinely validated against ionic conductivity or other collective transport measurements and used to interpret Li+ solvation and transport in battery electrolytes. We test this practice for 1.5 M LiFSI in dimethyl ketone with ab initio molecular dynamics, a fine-tuned machine learning potential, a newly developed polarizable force field, and a pairwise force field with charge scaling, compared with both Raman probes of the Li+ shell through computed bound-to-free cross-sections. The pairwise model reproduces the ionic conductivity, yet places 51% of anions in contact with Li+ (21% measured) and 4.8 ligands around the cation (4.0 from first principles). No adjustment of pair parameters removes the excess acetone, as ligand polarization is non-additive, costing a fifth ligand 22–25 kJ mol−1 of polarization energy, and favors acetone over the anion. The many-body models revise the experimental interpretation: Li+ moves vehicularly with a compact four-coordinate shell and ion pairing barely lowers the conductivity, which reflects the low viscosity of acetone rather than the fraction of solvent-separated ions. Agreement with transport therefore validates neither the solvation shell nor the transport mechanism, and we propose a validation protocol built on solvent-side spectroscopic observables.
Source: ChemRxiv
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226038531
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10