Work

One Density or Two? A Null Test of Whether Expansion and Growth Measure the Same Matter Density

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A recent manuscript (VEDE, version 3.0, graded at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24182409) contains one clean phenomenological question: its background equation makes the expansion history depend on an effective matter density Omega_m,eff, while its growth equation sources clustering with a smaller bare density Omega_m,0. Cut free of the framework, that is a two-density phenomenology with a single parameter, r = Omega_m,0/Omega_m,eff in (0,1]; the standard model is r = 1. This paper runs the test as a null test. The background is exactly degenerate: the expansion history is flat LambdaCDM at Omega_m,eff for every r (verified to 3.6 x 10^-15), and the joint chronometer-plus-BAO refit lands at chi2 = 27.254 on 41 points at (H0, Omega_m,eff) = (69.15, 0.2954) identically for all r. Profiling the growth equation over r on the five RSD f sigma8 points individually verified from the primary literature, with sigma8 fitted at each r, the likelihood is flat: chi2 spans 0.82 across r in [0.5, 1], with no interior minimum, because sigma8 absorbs the split (0.795 at r = 1 to 1.103 at r = 0.5) while S8 stays between 0.774 and 0.789. With sigma8 anchored at the Planck value 0.8111, the profile has a shallow minimum at r = 0.94, Delta chi2(r=1) = 0.28, and the Delta chi2 <= 1 interval is r in [0.834, 1]. At the manuscript's fitted split r = 0.924 the advantage over r = 1 is Delta chi2 = 0.18 (free amplitude) or 0.26 (anchored). Verdict: a null result -- expansion and growth currently measure the same matter density. The test's domain is late times, with the sound horizon imported from the standard early universe.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226039738
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10