Popular Sovereignty and Religious Authority in Contemporary Islamic Political Thought: A Comparative Analysis of Rached Ghannouchi and Ali Khamenei
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background: The relationship between Islam and democracy raises fundamental questions about popular sovereignty and religious authority, particularly when electoral preferences conflict with religious interpretations. Rached Ghannouchi and Ali Khamenei represent contrasting approaches to political legitimacy within contemporary Islamic thought. Objective: This study compares their respective conceptions of popular sovereignty and religious authority, as well as the institutional location of final political decision-making authority. Methods: A qualitative, library-based comparative approach to political thought was employed. Ghannouchi's primary writings and relevant secondary scholarship, including scholarly reconstructions of Khamenei's political thought, were examined through thematic textual analysis, focusing on political legitimacy, popular participation, religious authority, and constitutional decision-making. Results: Ghannouchi's conception of Muslim democracy emphasizes the reinterpretation of shura, popular authorization, constitutional participation, and pluralism without an institutional clerical veto. In contrast, the guardianship-based framework associated with Khamenei situates elected institutions within the constitutional authority of wilayat al-faqih. Although both approaches recognize Islamic principles and popular participation, they differ in how they define the institutional boundaries of electoral authority. Conclusion: The principal distinction concerns the sources of political legitimacy and the institutional location of final decision-making authority. This comparison demonstrates that Islamic democracy encompasses diverse arrangements of popular participation and religious governance rather than a single institutional model.
Authors: Nur Saadah Khudri, Syamsul Bahri
Language: English
Topic: Islamic Studies and History
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7226040086
