Recognised, Rated, Still Blind: Chinese Underground Banking and the Limits of AML Effectiveness in Thirty European Jurisdictions
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Chinese informal value transfer systems — Fei Qian (Fei Qian, Fei Ch'ien, Fei-Chen, Fei-Chien, Fei-ch'ien, Fei Tsien, Fie Ch'un, Feiquan, 飞钱, 飛錢, "flying money") and Dixia Qianzhuang ("underground banks") — have become a central settlement infrastructure for transnational money laundering in Europe. This article tests whether institutional recognition, EU membership and FATF-rated anti-money-laundering capacity predict enforcement against the phenomenon across thirty European jurisdictions. They do not. The analysis proceeds in two steps. Jurisdictions are clustered on structural variables (GDP, China trade share, CPI, golden-visa regimes, diaspora density, student quota, EU membership, and a FATF Capacity Index). Only after the clusters are defined are enforcement data introduced. Mapping the thirty jurisdictions onto a 3×3 recognition–enforcement matrix produces a striking result: the theoretically ideal configuration — dedicated national recognition plus dedicated enforcement (R3/E3) — is an empty cell. Furthermore, the "dark quadrant" (R1/E1) is also empty: even where recognition is entirely absent, enforcement occurs under generic fiscal labels. Two independent benchmarks fail to predict the outcome. The Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) and the FATF Capacity Index do not predict recognition or enforcement. The blind spot is not a corruption problem, a compliance problem or a capacity problem. It is a categorisation problem that cuts across the institutional-quality spectrum. The article argues that the categorisation failure is a failure of the intelligence cycle, which closes at the category. Policy implications follow for differentiated threat assessment, terminological standardisation, and a European measurement agenda.
Author: Jungmann, Alexander
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226352832
