Work

Cybernetics and the Structural Science of Self-Organizing Systems

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Self-organizing systems — biological cells, financial markets, immune systems, ant colonies, cognitive systems — maintain organized structure without requiring a central coordinating authority across different scales and substrates. Wiener's 1948 cybernetics established a foundational study of control and communication in animals and machines; Ashby's work developed explicit accounts of self-organizing systems. These research traditions investigated feedback, homeostasis, and regulation. Cybernetics and its successors developed substantial theories of feedback, regulation, and emergent organization. Yet a generally accepted account connecting the structural requirements of self-organization across different substrates remains contested. A 2025 review illustrates the continuing conceptual debate, while treating self-organization as a description that depends partly on the observer's purpose and scale (Gershenson, 2025). This paper proposes Cognitive Physics as the structural science of self-organizing systems, grounded in seven candidate structural invariants. The framework connects cybernetic accounts of feedback and regulation with complexity-science accounts of emergence, asking whether different mechanisms satisfy common organizational requirements across systems. Drawing on thermodynamics, information theory, dynamical systems, systems biology, and complexity science, it proposes that all seven conditions are jointly necessary for self-organization. The paper proposes nonexclusive functional correspondences between familiar cybernetic mechanisms and the seven conditions. Feedback can support input-output accountability; homeostasis can return a system toward a viable regime; and regulatory mechanisms can help coordinate conflicting demands. These are testable interpretations, not one-to-one identities. The framework also proposes a common structural perspective on first- and second-order cybernetics, while leaving their distinct epistemological questions unresolved. Ant colonies, markets, and immune systems can perform similar organizational work through very different mechanisms. This paper asks whether the same seven conditions are necessary in systems independently identified as self-organizing. If the conditions recur, a second question is whether grouping them into generative motion (M), structural constraint (S), and verification and preservation (V) explains more than other groupings. The exact product C = M × S × V, where C denotes organized output, is a further claim and requires comparison with other functional forms. The paper develops prospective tests of these ideas and uses the framework to distinguish possible causes of hallucination, sycophancy, and long-context failure in AI systems. The comparisons ask whether mechanisms studied in different disciplines perform similar organizational functions, and where that comparison breaks down. KEY FINDINGS Cognitive Physics is proposed as the structural science of self-organizing systems, grounded in seven candidate conditions hypothesized to be jointly necessary. Ant colonies, markets, and immune systems illustrate how different mechanisms may meet common organizational requirements. These correspondences do not establish universal necessity. The candidate model groups the conditions into generative motion (M), structural constraint (S), and verification and preservation (V). Its exact product, C = M × S × V, requires separate testing. Independent measurements, targeted interventions, comparisons with rival models, and transfer tests specify how the framework’s explanatory value could be supported or challenged.
Author: Bham, Amul
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226789394
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10