An orbitwise equality criterion for Ta's Problem 11.7 (arXiv:2505.08090v5, p. 27): extensions of the Kamada–Oshiro (2009/2010) examples
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Ta's Problem 11.7 (arXiv:2505.08090v5, p. 27) has answer no: extending the dihedral examples of Kamada and Oshiro (2009/2010), we characterize equality in the center term of the good-involution bound. For finite H generated by a conjugation subquandle X with |Z(H)|>=2, equality holds exactly when z O^{-1}=O for every central z and every H-conjugation orbit O. The criterion gives equality examples in Q8^d with center order 2^d, 3^d orbits and 2^(d*3^d) good involutions. Reflection families rederive the known good-involution counts, affine antiautomorphism group and symmetric-isomorphism classes. Inverse-closure permutes, rather than necessarily fixes, conjugation orbits, correcting Ta's Remark 2.14.
Authors: Ma, Haobo, Zhang, Wenlin
Institution: National University of Singapore
Language: English
Topic: Finite Group Theory Research
Subfield: Discrete Mathematics and Combinatorics
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keyword: quaternion group
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7227322409
