Does Numerology Foretell a Life? Preregistered Tests on Legislators, Olympians and Laureates, and a Lesson on Identity Leakage When Language Models Judge Blind
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Numerology, sun-sign astrology and the Japanese system sanmeigaku claim that the date of birth (and, for numerology, the name) shows whether a person will rise and when their life will turn. We tested 33 such predictions (excluding the blind matching test described below), preregistered on the Open Science Framework, on four populations with third-party records: 3,308 members of the Japanese House of Representatives, 120,798 national legislators worldwide, 156,386 Olympic athletes, and 8,296 nominees for the Nobel Prize or an Academy Award and Japanese Persons of Cultural Merit. None was supported. Leadership numbers and signs did not predict becoming a leader, an Olympic champion or a laureate, and beginnings, endings and deaths did not cluster in the predicted years; in the largest samples, several differences from chance lay within preregistered bounds of practical equivalence. A positive control, the relative-age effect among Olympic football and ice-hockey players, was detected with the same data and methods (30.0% born January–March against 24.7% of days; p = 1.8 × 10⁻²⁴). In a preregistered blind matching test, one language model wrote a numerology reading and a model from another provider picked the person's life summary out of five. When the reading model was given names, the judge matched readings to summaries well above chance, largely because the reading model wrote the names into the readings against its instructions. Given only the numbers, the judge matched at chance worldwide (20.4%) but at 28.0% in Japan. A follow-up, registered after the first submission, asked the judge to identify each person from the summary alone. In trials in which the judge had not identified the target by both name and exact date of birth, hit rates were 18.5% worldwide and 25.5% in Japan (95% CI 19.0–32.8%), and the judge chose summaries whose recalled birth dates reproduced the reading's numbers more often than chance. The systems did not foretell lives. A language model asked to judge readings blind can appear to succeed by recognising the person, and instructions alone do not prevent this.
Source: PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Author: TSUTOMU YAHAGI
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7227759476
