Basic Structure and the Federal Character of India
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The Constitution of India is the supreme law of the country. It is a written document that lays down the framework demarcating the fundamental basic code, structure, procedures, powers, and duties of the government and its organisations and the rights & duties of the citizens. It is the grundnorm through which "We, the People of India" constituted the Republic, created government institutions, guaranteed rights, and imposed limits through separation of powers across various vertical and horizontal levels, striking a perfect balance of power using the method of checks and balances. The text replaced colonial constitutional arrangements with a supreme, written framework of democratic self-government and now serves as a tool for the functioning of the government. India is described in Article 1 as a "Union of States", but the Constitution creates autonomous State governments as well as a powerful Union. It gives Parliament an extensive amendment power under Article 368, yet makes the Constitution, not Parliament, supreme. The Supreme Court's basic-structure doctrine emerged to resolve this second tension. The doctrine holds that Parliament may amend every provision of the Constitution but may not alter its essential constitutional identity. This paper argues that the basic-structure doctrine is the central judicial mechanism by which the Supreme Court has preserved the Constitution's character against both formal amendment and institutional overreach. The doctrine also frames the debate on federalism: India is neither conventionally federal nor simply unitary. It is a constitutionally federal, centrally weighted, and crisis-responsive Union whose balance is protected by judicial review.
Author: Pal Meena
Institution: University of Delhi
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7227807747
