Work

Formal Consistency and Numerical Reproducibility of a Proposed Algebraic Theory of Gravity

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This preprint presents an independent formal and computational assessment of Stephen Atkins' proposed algebraic reduction of gravitational and relativistic dynamics, published as version 3.3 on Zenodo (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23487834). All 23 numbered equations are examined with respect to mathematical consistency, dimensional correctness, physical assumptions, and the validity of their stated interpretations. The analysis identifies several formal inconsistencies, particularly in the proposed gravitational force equation, the Schwarzschild impact-parameter relation, the frame-dragging expression, and the photon-energy formulation. Established mathematical identities are distinguished from incomplete definitions and unsupported theoretical conclusions. A separate computational investigation examines the relationship between the published equations and the associated Python implementation. Independent orbital simulations are compared against NASA/JPL Horizons reference data for Mercury and Mars, using identical initial state vectors and documented numerical integration methods. The investigated three-dimensional extension of the published radial force law exhibits substantial deviations from the reference ephemerides. The results do not establish that every equation in the original manuscript is incorrect, nor do they constitute a universal disproof of all possible reformulations of the proposed theory. Instead, this work documents specific reproducible mathematical inconsistencies, limitations of the computational implementation, and unresolved validation requirements. German and English versions of the manuscript are provided together with reproducible Python scripts, NASA/JPL reference data, and machine-readable computational results. Research status: Independent preprint; not externally peer-reviewed. Version 2 – Technical Clarifications and Direct Reproduction of the Original Program This revised version addresses the five objections raised in Stephen Atkins' technical response (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24238119). It provides a detailed algebraic verification of Equation (1), clarifies the dimensional analysis and the interpretation of selected equations, and incorporates a direct numerical examination of the original Orbit.py integration code against NASA/JPL Horizons data. The new reproducibility tests include Newtonian control calculations, step-size convergence checks, independent numerical integration, and documented limitations. The revision preserves the original publication's scope while strengthening the transparency and reproducibility of its mathematical and computational findings.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7228099129
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10