The Justice Engagement Gap: Comparative Institutions and Anti-Trafficking Enforcement in the United States, Brazil, and China
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Human trafficking is nearly universal in law but highly uneven in prosecution. Existing cross-national research usually examines either trafficking prevalence or anti-trafficking enforcement, leaving unclear whether states respond at levels proportionate to estimated need. This article introduces the Justice Engagement Gap (JEG) framework to compare estimated trafficking prevalence with observable prosecutorial engagement while avoiding false numerical precision. The framework classifies trafficking prevalence levels and prosecutorial engagement separately, then evaluates whether their relationship indicates a narrow, moderate, high, or severe justice gap. I apply the framework to three institutionally contrasting cases: the United States, Brazil, and China. The comparison identifies three distinct pathways linking formal criminalization to uneven enforcement. In the United States, a narrow gap coexists with strong prosecutorial capacity but persistent underenforcement of labor trafficking. In Brazil, a high gap reflects fragmented federal coordination, dual legal tracks for trafficking and “slave labor,” and judicial bottlenecks that prevent investigations from yielding timely convictions. In China, a high gap reflects a qualitatively different problem: state perpetration, data suppression, and the absence of independent accountability. The article argues that anti-trafficking outcomes are best under- stood as institutional products shaped by capacity, coordination, transparency, and regime incentives rather than by statutory criminalization alone.
Source: SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Authors: Caye Lee, Mayank Kejriwal
Language: English
Topic: Sex work and related issues
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7228729172
