Human–ai Substantive Novelty Assessment
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The increasing integration of generative artificial intelligence into scientific research creates new opportunities for knowledge discovery while introducing additional challenges for evaluating scientific originality. Large language models can rapidly generate concepts, terminology, theoretical explanations, and interdisciplinary syntheses. However, linguistic originality does not necessarily imply substantive scientific novelty. A newly introduced expression may reproduce an established theoretical proposition, reinterpret a known mechanism, or rename an existing construct without providing additional explanatory or empirical value. This article examines the distinction between terminological innovation and substantive scientific contribution and proposes a human–AI assessment protocol for evaluating novelty at the level of scientific claims. Drawing on research concerning construct validity, jingle–jangle fallacies, scientific novelty measurement, semantic analysis, and AI-assisted literature evaluation, the proposed approach integrates structured claim decomposition, multidirectional prior-art retrieval, conceptual comparison, counterfactual substitution, discriminative testing, and evidence-based human judgment. The central argument is that substantive novelty should be evaluated according to the identifiable differences a proposed contribution makes to scientific understanding, explanation, prediction, measurement, or methodology—not according to the unfamiliarity of its terminology. The article introduces an evidence-oriented classification framework and outlines procedures for distinguishing conceptual duplication, incremental extension, potentially substantive contributions, and unresolved cases. The proposed protocol is conceptual and has not undergone empirical validation. Its intended contribution is to support transparent, critical, and reproducible novelty assessment in human–AI scientific collaboration while reducing the risk of treating sophisticated reformulations of existing knowledge as independent discoveries.
Author: Shaban, Roman
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7229263633
