The Price of Certainty: Entropy-Driven Collapse of Anticipation as a Common Origin of Misjudged Consequences and Self-Sustaining Repetitive Negative Thinking, with a Preventive Intervention Protocol
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Two families of everyday cognitive failure are usually studied apart: the systematic misjudgment of the consequences of one's own actions, and self-sustaining repetitive negative thinking (worry, catastrophizing, rumination) in otherwise healthy people. This paper argues that both arise from one mechanism, entropy-driven collapse of anticipation. The anticipating mind is modeled as an operator who allocates preparation across possible futures and pays an affective price proportional to the Shannon entropy of that allocation, in addition to a convex cost of being unprepared and a linear cost of dwelling on distressing scenarios. It is proved that any positive price of uncertainty makes every single-picture representation a strict local attractor, and that above an explicit threshold the single picture is globally optimal. The picture selected maximizes stakes-weighted probability minus distress, so an improbable catastrophe can win. A relief identity shows that collapse is felt as relief in proportion to the uncertainty removed, even when the selected picture is worse, which is the reward that sustains the loop. When disconfirming evidence is discounted after commitment, belief in the catastrophe converges to a self-confirming fixed point; this yields a formal definition of a dark path and a critical threshold for its persistence. A demand for engaging information adds a boredom branch, so that repetitive negative thinking is U-shaped in volatility, with a flow window that closes for people with a high price of uncertainty. The same structure explains why forecasts get the direction of effects right and their size wrong, why excluded outcomes recur, and why a positive floor of weight on every possibility is optimal under volatility. Extensions treat time to outcome (a deadline threshold with hysteresis), the body (commitments formed under physiological strain outlast recovery), co-rumination and amplified confirmation (dark paths that neither member of a pair would sustain alone), positive collapse in optimism and gambling, information avoidance versus compulsive checking, cultural absorption of uncertainty, and a computational price of plurality that restates the central fork between affective and computational origins of collapse. Humor, curiosity, absorbing activity, and lowered stakes act on different terms of one cost function, which gives a testable matching principle for interventions. An appendix derives the Calibrated Anticipation Protocol, a preventive intervention in which each module targets one parameter of the theory, modules are matched to a measured position on the volatility band, and delivery is timed to the moments when the theory predicts collapse; it includes a quarantine on conclusions formed under strain, deadline inoculation, a dyadic module, and an information policy that reverses with commitment. The protocol is a research instrument for trials, not clinical advice. All results are proved, illustrated with reproducible Python simulations (code included), connected to existing empirical findings, and accompanied by experiments that could falsify the theory. The paper builds on two books by the author, "Why We Misread the Consequences of Our Actions" and "Escaping the Dark Paths of the Mind". Keywordsanticipation; psychological entropy; repetitive negative thinking; worry; rumination; catastrophizing; intolerance of uncertainty; relief; self-confirming belief; boredom; flow; error management; forecasting; planning fallacy; humor; curiosity; information avoidance; co-rumination; active inference; preventive intervention Related works (cites): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18457545 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18474532 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18556979 https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.26532.64648 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18101601 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18099081 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18644028 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20100022
Author: Kriger, Boris
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7229457947
