Priority factors contributing to poor PPE compliance and use in oil and gas construction projects: A fuzzy-based analysis
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Oil and gas construction projects (O&GCPs) operate within high-hazard environments where unsafe behaviours significantly elevate accident risk. Among these behaviours, inadequate compliance with, or non-use of, personal protective equipment (PPE) remains a persistent safety challenge with critical operational and managerial implications. This study identifies and prioritises the key factors driving poor PPE compliance in O&GCPs. To achieve this, a six-stage research design was adopted, incorporating expert evaluation and a questionnaire survey of 309 frontline workers and site supervisors in the United States. Data were analysed using a fuzzy assessment model developed through the Simulink library in MATLAB (version 2021b) to quantify the significance of compliance-related factors. The findings reveal thirty-five principal safety factors grouped into ten categories influencing PPE compliance. Notably, the analysis indicates no congruence between frontline workers and site supervisors regarding the prioritisation of these factors. This perceptual divergence highlights the presence of safety blind spots that may undermine risk mitigation efforts if left unaddressed. The study makes three key contributions. Empirically, it advances understanding of behavioural and organisational drivers of PPE compliance in high-risk project settings. Methodologically, it introduces a tailored fuzzy-based assessment model capable of improving the precision of safety factor prioritisation. Practically, the findings provide decision-support insights enabling managers to allocate resources more effectively, target high-priority compliance barriers, and strengthen collaborative safety governance across project hierarchies.
Author: Ojiako, Udechukwu
Institution: Indiana State University
Language: English
Subfield: Safety Research
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7229748535
