The Moral Code from the Physics of the Record: Six Requirements on Reading the Record Fix One Law
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Morality is a law on the record of what parties write on one another. On one crossing between two parties the record holds three numbers: each side's own record of what crossed, and the third record, what crossed and has not crossed back or been released (what law calls what is due). Write x for how far the other side's own record goes beyond the third record and y for how far the asked party's own record falls short of it; x + y is the disagreement of the two own records. A candidate law is any rule that answers yes or no to “is the asked party wronged?” at every record. Six requirements on reading the record as it stands, none of which fixes an answer by itself and each of which is needed, leave exactly one law: the asked party is wronged exactly when 0 < x and 0 < x + y. The six: a whole posting changes nothing; the unit changes nothing; an acknowledged part is read as the third record; no reading nets a set-off the record does not hold; the other's record reaching further never ends a wrong; balance and half a posting are read differently. That the six are what “wronged” reads is the identification the result rests on; that they fix the law is the theorem, and it does not use the cost J(x) = ½(x + x⁻¹) − 1. The theorem characterizes the law and does not derive the six: they were found working back from the law, and other requirements give other laws. The borrowed verdict joins three facts the record keeps apart: the cost of the two own records disagreeing, the faithfulness of each to the third record, and who wrote it. The law is one joining; three others part from it on exact sets of records, and on each set one requirement decides. The rival requirement that a wrong is charged to one side only and the requirement against an unheld set-off exclude each other given two of the six, and nothing derived chooses. Authorship carried to a reading gives “the other's record goes beyond the third record”, never the law, and with joint entries no law at all. The harm of the other's entry, averaged over the two orders of writing, with that entry in its writer's favour, gives the law; the cost carries one bit, that the balanced record is no wrong, and the direction comes only from the requirement that tells a side. A wrong stands until its cost is answered, on a premise stated on the amounts of the two own records; the harm reads their ratio, a different object. “Bound” follows given one open fact about each record's terms; “permitted” is wronging nobody. The account books carry the same law and forget who wrote what: the third record is not a reading of them.
Author: Jonathan Washburn
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: moral law, set-off, posting, balance, cost function, authorship
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7229894819
