Work

Recovering Eliza Farrow and Mary E. Rhodes: The "Philippi Mummies" and the Archival Deconstruction of Institutional Mythology

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: For 138 years, two mummified women have been displayed at the Barbour County Historical Museum in Philippi, West Virginia, described as anonymous subjects of embalmer Graham Hamrick's secret formula. This article shows that the popular account does not survive archival scrutiny. Using a four-phase documentary convergence method that cross-checks the Lewis County Register of Deaths with digitized records of the West Virginia Hospital for the Insane at Weston, it identifies the women as Eliza Farrow and Mary E. Rhodes, patients at Weston who died on February 13, 1888, and were transferred to Hamrick the next day under the state's 1882 Act for the Promotion of Medical Science. The key evidence is a March 27, 1889, Executive Committee authorization, recovered from a legacy CD-ROM collection at the West Virginia and Regional History Center, which names both women and records family consent for their preservation. The article also examines the patent record, the "Mrs. L. Warner" oral tradition and other parts of the legend, and argues that the anonymity endured not for lack of evidence but through agnotology: the authority of display, citation cascades and narrative displacement.
Language: English
Subfield: Conservation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7230991781
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10