What Lies Behind Our Motives? Self-Deception, Human Agency, and the Limits of Explanation in Light of Differentiated Realism
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A lecturer prepares a lesson carefully, hoping her students will understand. When nobody praises her work, she feels disappointed. Recognition evidently matters to her, but does that establish that the prospect of praise influenced her preparation? Even if it did, her concern for the students might have been genuine. What would discovering this additional motive explain, and what would remain to be understood about her action?Drawing on Simler and Hanson's account of hidden social incentives, this article examines how motives can influence conduct without being fully recognized by the person acting. Evidence that social incentives affect behavior does not automatically establish what motivated a particular individual. Nor does the discovery of an unrecognized influence suffice to establish self-deception, which requires further examination of how the agent formed and maintained her understanding of her own conduct.The lecturer may have chosen a particular example partly because she anticipated admiration. If her concern for the students also contributed, discovering the influence of recognition would complete rather than replace her explanation. If that concern played no part in the choice, her professed reason would fail to explain it. Whether the example benefited her students remains a further question. Differentiated Realism examines these relations by specifying what is to be explained and what evidence warrants the proposed explanation. Discovering why someone acted, understanding how a motive influenced her judgment, and assessing whether the action was worthwhile require distinctions that the disclosure of a hidden incentive alone cannot supply.What the lecturer discovers about her motives may also change how she acts. Recognizing a desire for admiration need not require her to abandon teaching or wait until that desire disappears. She may examine which decisions it has influenced, correct those that were distorted, and continue work supported by reasons she can independently justify. Her attention, understanding, and acquired dispositions have shaped her conduct, yet these same capacities allow her to examine and gradually change it. The article develops an account of moral self-knowledge in which the living agent remains capable of correcting her judgments and actions while her understanding of her own motives remains incomplete. The accompanying Qur'anic appendix examines how remembrance, worship, and accountability contribute to this continuing moral formation. AI-assisted tools were used for language editing, including grammar, clarity, and stylistic consistency. The author retains full responsibility for the arguments, interpretations, and final text.
Author: Darwich, Samer
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7232058554
