Searching for clarity:Conceptualising and responding to uncertainty in UK registered designs
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Determining the subject matter of a registered design is critical to the operation of the design system. Surprisingly, however, UK law does not yet offer a complete or coherent response to the difficulties of inconsistency and lack of clarity which may arise in construing design representations. There is also a growing divergence in how these issues are addressed in UK and EU-level case law, particularly in the context of post-grant invalidation. Responding to these developments, this article proposes an overarching conceptualisation of and response to the difficulties that may arise in determining design subject matter which moves beyond labels such as “unity” and “clarity” to focus on uncertainty of subject matter. It is argued that a validly registrable “design” must have only one embodiment that is unambiguously, consistently and intelligibly communicated through the design representation alone, and that failure to meet these requirements justifies both pre-grant refusal and post-grant invalidation.
Author: Cornwell, Jane
Language: English
Topic: Intellectual Property Law
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233519746
