One Theorem, Two Directions: Determinations about Unverifiable States and Operative Standards
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Institutions issue determinations about states that no admissible means can verify: whether a patient in irreversible coma retains consciousness, whether an AI system is conscious, whether a passage in a paper was written by a person or by a model. For those who receive such a determination, it settles how rights and responsibilities are allocated. The HYC Theorem states that where such a state cannot be verified and a determination about it is nonetheless issued, the deciding institution has operated an operative standard, that is, a rule mapping observable indicators and procedural facts to the determination. The theorem can be read in two directions. Read forward, an institution that faces a deadline and cannot abstain needs a standard, so the standard can be designed in advance and with the participation of those it will assess. Read backward, every issued determination shows that a standard was running at the time, so those assessed gain a footing from which to name that standard and contest it. The two readings are the active and the passive side of the same conditional. Where determinations cannot be checked against the state itself, the legitimacy of an institution depends on the procedures by which its standard is formed and maintained, and the two readings give the moment to build those procedures and the footing from which to call them into question.
Author: Yamada, Kenji
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233540796
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
