The Protective Insulin Withdrawal Hypothesis (PIWH): β-Cell Withdrawal and Insulin Resistance as a Coordinated, Protective and Reversible Response to Chronic Substrate Overload
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Type 2 diabetes is conventionally described as a progressive disease in which insulin resistance is followed by β-cell “exhaustion” and irreversible failure. This concept note proposes an alternative interpretation, the Protective Insulin Withdrawal Hypothesis (PIWH). The PIWH holds that, under chronic substrate overload, the reduction of insulin secretion by β-cells and the development of insulin resistance in peripheral tissues are two coordinated parts of one protective response of the whole organism. Insulin is a storage signal; when storage capacity is exceeded, further insulin would drive energy into cells that can no longer handle it. Withdrawal of insulin is therefore interpreted not as failure, but as a regulated protective step that accepts rising glucose as its visible price. The hypothesis integrates evidence on early hyperinsulinaemia, β-cell dedifferentiation rather than loss, rapid recovery of β-cell function after substrate reduction, and the environment-dependence of type 2 diabetes in genetically similar populations. It implies that metabolic dysfunction should be detected earlier through insulin-based rather than glucose-based markers, that the primary intervention is reduction of substrate load (including the frequency of food intake), and that early and advanced functional dysfunction is largely reversible. Testable predictions are stated.
Author: Yunusah, Abdul Fattah
Language: English
Subfield: Endocrinology, Diabetes and Metabolism
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233549984
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
