Does any established principle forbid light and gravitational waves from following different light cones? A theory-side ledger
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: No established principle we found forbids light and gravitational waves from following different light cones in every framework. As a theory-side companion to a ledger of observational bounds, this note records for each principle or no-go argument what it assumes and whether it forbids, constrains or does not address such a difference. A difference between the cones of massless fields is forbidden only by exact Lorentz invariance with no background. Known physics already predicts a nonzero difference: today the photon cone is wider by about 5e-82, so light leads. In the spontaneous-breaking case, the causality criterion of de Rham and Tolley, applied here to GW170817, would require a gravitational-wave lead below about 8e-18 to 8e-19 (an order-of-magnitude condition). Explicitly Lorentz-violating theories allow a difference up to the observational bounds, at two costs: protecting matter from Lorentz violation, and consistency with black-hole thermodynamics, which remains open. A small organising note; the closest reviews are credited. A deposited script computes its numbers.
Author: Nguyen, Dat
Language: English
Subfield: Nuclear and High Energy Physics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233553063
