Work

The Illusion Of Choice

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The existence of a formal option to refuse is frequently treated as sufficient justification for acommercial transaction. This article argues that such a defence is inadequate when sellers designthe conditions under which people understand, enter, repeat, or exit that transaction. Througha critical narrative synthesis of experimental research, financial records, corporate documents,legal proceedings, and regulatory interventions, it examines gambling, mobile games, food, sexualmedia and advertising, durable goods, and subscriptions. The comparison identifies distinctmechanisms: impaired control, distorted information, repeated inducement, costly exit, andrestricted repair or continued use. These mechanisms are not interchangeable, and evidence ofharm does not by itself establish deliberate exploitation. Nevertheless, the cases show why observedpurchasing and continued payment cannot automatically be interpreted as informed, enduringendorsement. The article develops a responsibility framework centred on knowledge, control,foreseeability, and feasible prevention. It distinguishes the protection of workers, consumers, andessential services from the preservation of incumbent firms and revenue models. Proposed reformsinclude enforceable refusal, intelligible pricing, protections for children, repairability, proportionatedurability obligations, and practical cancellation rights. The argument is normative and comparativerather than a new estimate of population harm: technological progress should increase people’seffective command over their lives, and commercial freedom cannot supply a blanket defence forpractices that predictably undermine it.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233554797
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: