"Do No Small Evil": Bottom-Line Morality as the Foundation of a Self-Sufficient Good Society — A Six-Part Framework
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This six-part study asks whether a society can be good without requiring anyone to be good-hearted. It begins from a single classical injunction — do not commit a small evil on the grounds that it is small — and treats it as the whole of moral obligation. Two stipulations follow: a "good person" is one who never actively harms others and who compensates for harm caused by negligence; and "evil" comprises those two failures and nothing else. Everything beyond them is permitted. The question is then what such a society must build. Three derivational principles do the work. Causal transmission: an action that foreseeably and avoidably raises the probability of harm is itself harmful, within the scope of institutional rather than incidental conduct. Cumulative effect: conduct harmless in each instance may become harmful as a series, so that the multiset of actions, not only the single act, is a proper object of moral judgment. Equivalent exchange: systematic free-riding through unequal exchange is harm by another route. From these follow five institutional requirements — a government that prevents harm rather than dispensing good; officials bound by ordinary professional standards and stripped of privilege; taxation reconceived as payment for public goods; compulsory education as the block on intergenerational transmission; and provision for the poor justified as hazard removal rather than charity. The argument then defends three consequences that many readers will find objectionable: bystanders owe no general duty of rescue; the disappearance of opportunities for benevolence is a mark of success rather than loss; and the clamour for more good deeds tacitly presupposes a society riddled with holes. Five further papers extend the framework — economic organisation through contributory rather than capital claims; a topological description of moral equivalence together with a testable neural hypothesis; the spontaneous emergence of small kindnesses once evil ceases to pay; a formalisation via the Price equation; and the extension of equivalent exchange to dependants, intimates, and animals capable of attachment.
Author: 赵, 磊
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233558141
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
