The Central Ten Gender-Responsive Needs and Recidivism: A Gender-Based Analysis in Justice-Impacted Youth
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Feminist scholars posit that young women and men have unique risk factors for crime, prompting the development of gender-responsive theories of criminal behaviour. However, there is mixed evidence regarding whether these hypothesized risk factors are in fact uniquely predictive of recidivism in youth. Thus, this study explored whether ten factors identified as being particularly important for women (e.g., trauma, substance misuse, financial instability, maladaptive coping; coined the Central Ten; Brown, 2019) were more predictive of recidivism in a sample of young women (n = 132) vs. young men (n = 536). The Central Ten gender responsive needs were extracted from a preexisting database with information derived from clinical notes used to prepare court-ordered psychological assessments. Results illustrated that young women exhibited significantly more Central Ten needs than men. However, contrary to the hypothesis, the only needs that were significantly predictive of recidivism in the mixed-gender sample were a lack of social support, procriminal attitudes, and unsafe/unstable housing. Gender-based analyses showed no significant relationship between the Central Ten needs and recidivism in young women. Future research should examine whether the Central Ten needs function as distal factors in young women that influence the development of proximal, established risk factors for criminal behaviour.
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7233561752
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
