Work

An audit and restoration of the vector-sieve estimates for primes of the form m² + n² + 1 with p + 2 almost prime

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Nath and Xie (Acta Arith. 223 (2026), 51–82; arXiv:2501.16723v3) state that there are ≫ x (log x)^(−5/2) primes p ≤ x with p = m² + n² + 1 and Ω(p+2) ≤ 9. The proof combines a semi-linear and a linear sieve in a vector sieve, Iwaniec's switching principle and Richert's weights, and ends with a numerical inequality H > 0. This note recomputes that inequality. Findings: (1) The linear sieve functions used in the computation, both as printed and in the authors' Matlab files, solve the delay system without the factor 1/s, so that the computed lower function exceeds the computed upper function. With the correct functions the quantities reported as G(0.4230, 0.0249) = 0.001378 and H(0.17, 0.25, 0.449, 0.011) = 1.2690 become −23.73 and −34.28. (2) The reported values are reproduced from the authors' code to three digits (−0.0009 and 1.2625) once a second artefact is taken into account, an optimiser called on an empty constraint set; this identifies the cause. (3) Three constants in the switched term (Proposition 4.2) need correction: the Wirsing constant lacks the Euler factor of the prime 2, the joint singular series of the two linear sieves has the wrong sign in its factors, and one inequality is reversed. Together they halve the switched term. (4) The levels in the switching step can be chosen more freely. With these changes the method of the paper gives Ω(p+2) ≤ 17; with the constants as printed it gives Ω(p+2) ≤ 59. With the Buchstab fixed point of Part XIV (doi:10.5281/zenodo.24231797) the bound improves to Ω(p+2) ≤ 15. These statements assume Propositions 3.10, 4.1 and 4.3 of the Nath–Xie paper; the numerical values come from floating-point grid searches, not interval arithmetic. All numbers are produced by a single script in the Python standard library (about 15 seconds). Code and data: https://github.com/Ruqing1963/nath-xie-sieve-audit
Author: Chen, Ruqing
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233576326
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: