Work

Abiogenesis: A Critical Survey of All Proposals and the Case for Closure-First Life — Introduction to a Series of New Proposals

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This is a synthesis and hypothesis paper, not an experimental result. Autocatalytic sets are due to Kauffman (1971), wet-dry cycling to Deamer and others, vent chemistry to Russell / Wachtershauser, RNA World to Gilbert / Sutherland / Szostak, and metabolism-first ideas to Wachtershauser / Russell. None of those ideas are claimed as original here. The contribution of this paper is: 1. A systematic comparison of nine major abiogenesis proposals against the same five requirements: Feedstock, Energy, Heredity, Metabolism, Compartment.2. A formalization called Closure-First: life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed — defined as catalytic closure + temporal closure + compartmental closure, expressed as P(S_{t+1} | S_t, E_t) > P(S_{t+1} | E_t).3. Five falsifiable predictions and a series roadmap (Papers II-VI) to test them. No claim in this paper is presented as experimentally proved. The falsifiers in Section 6 define what would kill the theory. This is Paper I — Introduction. Papers II-VI in the series will test one prediction each: the cycling threshold, hysteresis / memory, minimal closure size, RNA downstream, and geochemical signature. Abstract:Abiogenesis has no shortage of proposals. It has a shortage of a criterion for choosing between them. We survey nine major proposals: Primordial Soup, Hydrothermal Vent, RNA World, Metabolism-First, Lipid World, Clay World, Panspermia, Deep Hot Biosphere, and Thermodynamic proposals. We show each explains one necessary condition for life — feedstock, energy, heredity, metabolism, compartment — and fails to explain the others. We propose a unifying criterion: Causal Closure. Life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed: its present increases the probability of its own past. RNA, proteins, lipids, and membranes are not origins. They are co-options of a network that already had closure. Key words: abiogenesisorigin of lifeautocatalytic setsRNA worldhydrothermal ventsprebiotic chemistrycausal closurehypothesis
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233577585
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: