Work

Beyond Automation: Exploring Employees’ Perceptions of Artificial Intelligence, Job Insecurity, and Workplace Identity in The Modern Workplace

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become a part of every organisation's day-to-day operations and is a factor in the way work is being assigned, done, directed and checked. Discussions about this change have primarily been around automation, efficiency and jobs, but also about how an employee's sense of security, competence in their role, independence and sense of identity at work is affected by AI. In this article, we delve into the interconnections between employees' attitudes toward AI, their feelings of job insecurity, and workplace identity. The study was of qualitative, interpretive, documentary design and secondary data analysis was done using reflexive thematic analysis (RTA) based on peer reviewed studies, systematic reviews and reports of international organizations such as ILO and OECD. The five interrelated themes were: (1) Ambivalence about the use of AI: some experiences it as a tool to augment their work while others worry about being monitored, deskilled, and displaced; (2) Anticipatory fear of loss: fear of job loss can occur even if the number of jobs does not decrease; (3) Remediated and reinforced professional identity: when AI is used to complement their job, it enhances their sense of competence, while when it digitises their core job, it threatens it; (4) Algorithmic management reconfigures autonomy: when automating parts of their job, employees' autonomy is reassigned, while when parts of their job are kept by humans and coded into algorithms, they lose some autonomy; (5) Algorithmic management experiences depend on the organizational support, the transparency of communication, participation, and reskilling. From a theoretical perspective, the study synthesizes the concepts of job insecurity, social and/or organizational identification, technology acceptance and resistance, sociotechnical systems and human capital, and is able to articulate a framework beyond the deterministic replacement stories. The reality is that HR teams and leaders need to approach the integration of AI as a transformational journey rather than simply a technological fix, and have to do so. It concludes by proposing that although the technical difficulty is a consideration, a more important one is how well staff can feel secure, competent and valued as professionals in the context of the integration of AI.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7233587568
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: