Work

Are Police Killing More People Than They Used To? A Sampling and Analysis Protocol for Within-Agency Comparisons of Fatal Police Shootings, 1985–1994 vs. 2015–2025

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This protocol fixes the design of a study comparing, within the same U.S. law enforcement agencies, the number of people shot and killed by on-duty officers in 1985–1994 and 2015–2025. It was deposited before collection of the remaining sampled agencies. The protocol defines a sampling frame of 309 local police departments and sheriff's offices that served at least 100,000 residents in 1985–1994. It reports an outcome-blind audit of each agency's local newspaper archive, restricts the study universe to the 155 agencies with a usable archive, and records a stratified random draw (seed 20261115): 28 certainty agencies serving 500,000 or more, plus 28 sampled agencies. It also sets the counting rules, a per-agency recall check against Fatal Encounters, the two estimands (a pooled ratio and a design-weighted typical-agency ratio, in counts and population-adjusted rates), and the sensitivity analyses. The protocol is partly retrospective: pre-1995 counts for 43 agencies were assembled before it was written. Those agencies enter the main analysis only if drawn. The code and data that produced the frame, audit, and draw are in the linked repository at tag protocol-v1.0.
Author: Nix, Justin
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233588939
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: