Work

A comment on "Comparing positive rates in traditional articles and registered reports within sport and exercise science: A stage 2 registered report"

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Human verification files: Tsai et al. (2026), I4R auditDeposit `claims_patched.R`: the AI claims script, with one human patch at lines 357-360 and 432-433. The script read the printed intervals in article Tables 2-4 from pdftotext output, and that parsing broke under a different pdftotext layout. The patch types those printed values in from the article PDF (p. 6). No statistical code was changed.Output is in `claims_patched_out.txt`. `independent.R`: independent checks written by the human verifier. They rebuild the data from the raw cells and use methods the AI did not use: a cluster-robust logistic GLM, a logistic GLMM, an article-level Welch t-test, the Newcombe hybrid-score interval without continuity correction, Fisher exact tests, and a separate implementation of the Fleiss calculation.Output is in `independent_out.txt`.
Author: Dong, Trang
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233591669
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: