Work

26. 2024-10-09 Judge Hila Gurevitz flawed Transcript, purported to be a "Hearing Protocol"

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Attached are 3 records: 1. 2024-10-09 Judge Hila Gurevitz flawed Transcript, purported to be a "Hearing Protocol" 2. 2024-12-12 Legal position letter by the Administration of Courts, provided to Joseph Zernik when Judge Gurevitz refused to render a Protocol. Attached to it is the mandatory Work Procedure 03-14, including the detailed instructions for editing a transcript into a formal Protocol. 3. 2026-08-03 Opinion 01/26 "Various Aspects of Protocol Administeration" by Ombudsman of the Judiciary, Judge Asher Kula. He starts with noting that the issue had generated numerous complaints, so he decided to issue a general opinion on the subject. He then states the obvious; rendering a protocol is a duty established by law, specifically after the 2008 Amendment 51 to the Courts Law, 1984. This list of records already tells the story: A judge that refused to comply with the law, regadless of repeat requests and an opinion letter by the Administration of Courts. Once her "court’s pilot" ruse had collapsed, she found another, and finally she simply ruled that a flawed, deliberately corrupted transcript was a duly rendered protocol. Rendering a hearing protocol is required by law. It is the judge’s duty. However, Israeli judges often0 try to avoid rendering a hearing protocol. A hearing withuot a protocol is an "informal, off the record hearing," which such judges prefer.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233592547
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: