Too Few People in the Same Room at the Same Time: A Pre-specified Co-Presence Density Test of Closed Venue-Based Dating Apps
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: No venue-based dating app we found survived on spontaneous check-ins at the same bar or club. We test whether expected mutual matches per participant and check-in evening separate closed products from working in-person formats. Six entries from five of sixteen closed or dormant products were modelled and compared with four working formats, including speed dating and one documented app launch night in a full club. A Monte Carlo co-presence model, a success criterion and eight perturbation scenarios were pre-specified before any model run in an internal, dated protocol, not publicly deposited. The pre-specified strong criterion failed: the best threshold, 0.20 expected matches per evening, separated all closed from all working cases in 73.5% of 2,000 parameter draws, short of the required 80%, and five of eight perturbation scenarios fell below 80%. A post-hoc analysis supports a weaker claim: the five closed check-in or map formats delivered 0.003–0.03 expected matches per evening (medians), below the weakest working format in 99.95% of draws (median gap 1.1 orders of magnitude). They needed roughly 9–13.5 checked-in users per venue and evening but had 0.14–1.7, a gap of 8- to 68-fold. In a descriptive, not pre-specified analysis, documented acquisition campaigns, including one with an estimated 450,000 downloads, moved venue-level density by less than a factor of two. That matching markets need thickness is well known; we contribute a pre-specified, quantitative cross-case test of it for venue-based dating. The results are consistent with working formats succeeding by bundling participants into one time slot. Files: paper (PDF); case table with sources, stored model outputs, model code (seed 20261028), redacted English translation of the internal protocol and LaTeX source (ZIP).
Author: Bieg, Michael
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233595217
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
