Informed consent waivers in research using extracted human primary teeth: evidence, ethics, and a decision framework
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background Extracted human primary teeth are frequently used in in vitro dental research. However, the circumstances in which informed consent may ethically be waived for their secondary research use have received limited systematic examination. Objective To examine the ethical, legal, and governance considerations surrounding research with extracted human primary teeth; to assess how consent and related safeguards are reported in influential experimental studies; and to develop a practical ethical decision-making framework for researchers and research ethics committees (RECs), to be applied in conjunction with the legal and regulatory requirements of the relevant jurisdiction. Methods The study comprised three integrated components. First, a scoping review of the bioethical and legal literature concerning the educational or research use of extracted human teeth was conducted in PubMed and Scopus. Second, a citation-prioritised audit examined ethical reporting in the 30 most-cited eligible in vitro studies using extracted human primary teeth published from 2016 onwards. Extracted variables included REC or institutional review board (IRB) approval, informed consent, sample provenance, coding or anonymisation, storage, and secondary use. Third, the findings were interpreted through a normative analysis informed by the 2024 World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki, the Declaration of Taipei, the 2016 CIOMS Guidelines, relevant Spanish legislation, and complementary ethical perspectives concerning autonomy, child protection, dignity, privacy, justice, and research governance. Results The scoping review identified three publications addressing ethical or legal aspects of using extracted human teeth, none of which specifically examined consent waivers for anonymised primary teeth. Of the 30 citation-prioritised experimental records assessed, 27 met the eligibility criteria. REC or IRB approval was reported in 21 studies (77.8%), whereas only eight (29.6%) reported any form of informed consent: five reported written consent (18.5%), one oral consent (3.7%), and two reported informed consent without specifying its form (7.4%). Full text was successfully retrieved and assessed for 24 of the 27 studies (88.9%); the remaining three were assessed from the available abstracts. Across the accessible material, ethical reporting was heterogeneous, and no study described a formal anonymisation procedure or provided an explicit ethical justification for waiving consent. To our knowledge, this is the first framework specifically designed to structure REC/IRB deliberation on consent waivers for research using extracted human primary teeth, providing a practical tool for case-specific assessment of secondary research use. Conclusions Ethical reporting in experimental research using extracted primary teeth remains largely limited to statements of committee approval. Biological sample, residual biological material, and healthcare waste are distinct functional categories, and classification as waste determines only how an object is disposed of, not whether it may be retained for research. Neither anonymisation nor disposal status is, by itself, sufficient to justify a consent waiver. We propose a hybrid model in which a waiver may be considered alongside a retained duty of transparent information and a respected right to object, and we report a case in which a competent REC granted such a waiver under these conditions. Clinical trial number Not applicable
Source: BMC Medical Ethics
Language: English
Topic: Ethics in Clinical Research
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,290
OpenAlex ID: W7233596893
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to:
