Work

An Innovation Compass: A translation concept for technology-based innovation in health care and the public sector

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Technology-based innovations in health care and the public sector rarely fail for lack of an idea or of technical feasibility; they fail to achieve sustained impact. Those who develop, advise on and fund innovations cannot hold all the knowledge that an innovation – especially nowadays – requires, and they frequently do not know what they do not know. Originating from this epistemic problem, systemic blind spots and reductionist approaches, this paper proposes an Innovation Compass: a translation concept that weighs an innovation along four equivalent perspectives like the directions of a compass: 1. Users and Affected Parties, 2. Technology, 3. Economy, and 4. System. The concept derives from the authors’ years of work with public economic developers, entrepreneurs and in teaching, system design and research; it was consolidated during the scientific accompaniment of a municipal project in which an innovation ecosystem with a realworld laboratory was designed and implemented.The Innovation Compass advances three conceptual propositions: First, an innovation is more likely to achieve sustained impact if the four perspectives are developed together from the outset than if one or more of them are underrepresented or even neglected. Second, the Innovation Compass is a tool of translational science: it addresses the translation of knowledge among all four perspectives, on which the impact of an innovation in the system depends. Third, innovation emerges above all at the interfaces between adjacent perspectives, where the translation work is located. These interfaces are presented as Hot Zones, for they can cause friction between sectors on the one side; on the other side, they are the areas where complexity and system integration are managed, leading to cross-sectoral impact. These four Hot Zones are fields of action rather than units of measurement. The Innovation Compass is intended to stand alongside existing instruments and to place them in a common context. The paper relates the concept to existing frameworks, discusses its limitations and identifies open questions how hypotheses derived from these propositions can be examined in a retrospective study design and whether a uniform maturity scale is appropriate or whether maturity should be defined per program, per innovation, per direction.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233605370
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: