Work

Separating Damage, Complexity and Criticality in African Cyber Incidents: An Evidence-Constrained Framework with Twelve Illustrative Cases

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Public discussion of cyber incidents tends to merge four separate questions: whether a target is socially important, whether an attack was technically complex, whether systems were exposed or compromised, and whether the event caused real operational harm. In African analysis this blurring is costly, because public reporting is highly uneven. The article develops a closed framework around three instruments built and tested on 15,789 event records in the Maryland Cyber Events Database: the Damage Severity Index (KSM), an ordinal measure of technical-operational consequence; the Complexity Index (KoI), a transparent sum of observable persistence, lateral movement, evasion and multi-stage execution; and the Criticality Indicator (KrI), which flags critical-sector status without inflating severity. Rather than a new composite score, it adds two evidential rules: functional criticality is described apart from legal sector labels, and missing technical detail is recorded as not assessable rather than as absence. Twelve public incidents illustrate the approach: severe operational disruption can coincide with sparse reporting, data compromise can be serious without equivalent service interruption, and socially essential digital services can be critical outside conventional utility categories. The framework thus supports consistent comparison without letting importance, identity or reputation replace evidence.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7233606935
FWCI:
Cites: 11
Cited by:
Related to: