Sustainability success in language education: A critical conceptual synthesis
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Sustainability-oriented language education connects language learning with ecological understanding, action, and relationships among languages, knowledges, and communities. These purposes complicate judgments of success because a well-written text, a reported disposition, and a claim of knowledge co-creation may concern different achievements. This critical conceptual synthesis compares Eco-ELT, transformative language teaching for sustainability, language education for sustainable development, and transepistemic education. Drawing on argument-based evaluation, reasoning about educational purpose, and assessment validation, it examines educational aims, evaluation of achievement, and comparison of success claims. The literature supports comparison of aims and practices, but its uneven evidence base does not support an overall effectiveness ranking. Resource appraisal, task performance, self-report, and conceptual argument support different conclusions and require justification suited to each claim. The contribution distinguishes extending evidence-based support for an asserted achievement, adding an explicitly justified educational criterion, and silently substituting another achievement or standard. Further evidence may strengthen a claim, it but cannot by itself justify giving priority to a new purpose. Existing purposes also remain open to criticism. The synthesis explains how comparison can preserve differences in achievement while requiring justification of both the evidence and the authority to determine educational values.
Author: Tin T. Dang
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7233607602
