Packaging reverse logistics in Bahia, Brazil: participatory importance ratings to inform materiality assessment in S-LCA
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Stakeholder participation can inform the selection of social topics in Social Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA), but importance ratings alone do not establish materiality. This study develops and applies a structured procedure to describe and compare the importance assigned to 27 pre-selected social impact subcategories in packaging reverse logistics in southern and southwestern Bahia, Brazil. Four respondent groups were analysed separately: recyclable material pickers, waste generators, public authorities, and S-LCA practitioners. An individual online questionnaire administered between May and September 2024 used a 10-point numerical importance scale and common written definitions. Group means were used descriptively, and between-group comparisons employed Kruskal-Wallis tests, Holm-adjusted Dunn post-hoc comparisons, and signed rank-biserial correlations with bootstrap 95% confidence intervals. Thirteen subcategories yielded statistically significant overall differences at the exploratory 0.05 threshold. The largest pairwise effect estimates involved recyclable material pickers and public authorities or S-LCA practitioners in Worker-related subcategories. Non-significant comparisons were treated as inconclusive regarding equivalence. Of 1,242 individual item ratings analysed, 830 (66.8%) were at the scale maximum, indicating substantial upper-end concentration that restricts fine discrimination among highly rated topics. The instrument was not piloted or cognitively pre-tested in this application, and equivalence of item interpretation across groups was not established. The findings provide context-specific participatory evidence for broader materiality assessment alongside information on social impacts, affected populations, vulnerability, and decision relevance; yet they do not measure impact occurrence, social performance, or causal mechanisms underlying respondents' judgements. The documented procedure provides a basis for further applications, subject to local adaptation and validation.
Source: Waste Management
Language: English
Subfield: Environmental Engineering
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,450
OpenAlex ID: W7233607804
