Work

ALADIN Galactic Plasma Dynamics v0.5 — Bessel J₀ Cylindrical Eigenmode Verification & Second-Order Numerical Convergence

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: ALADIN Galactic Plasma Dynamics v0.7 Cylindrical Bessel Eigenmode Verification — Higher Radial Spectra, Weighted Orthogonality, and Nonaxisymmetric Modes Overview ALADIN Galactic Plasma Dynamics v0.7 presents a numerical verification campaign for cylindrical Bessel eigenmodes, extending the fundamental axisymmetric (J_0) benchmark to higher radial modes and nonaxisymmetric azimuthal families. The release documents results from the ZP-61 verification series, including analytical eigenvalue comparisons, grid-convergence studies, independent eigenpair calculations, weighted orthogonality, wave-frequency measurements, and preliminary long-time temporal-integrity assessments. The primary objective is to establish the accuracy of the reduced cylindrical spectral operators before their use in more complex magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) calculations. This release concerns numerical verification of established mathematical equations. It does not claim experimental validation of a new plasma theory or full MHD stability. 1. Mathematical formulation The axisymmetric radial cylindrical Laplacian is [\mathcal L_0 f =\frac{1}{r}\frac{d}{dr}\left(r\frac{df}{dr}\right).] Its regular radial eigenfunctions satisfy [\mathcal L_0 f=-\lambda f,] with solutions [f(r)=J_0(kr), \qquad \lambda=k^2.] For the unit-radius cylinder with a homogeneous Neumann boundary condition, [J_0'(kR)=0,] or equivalently, [J_1(kR)=0.] The first positive radial eigenvalue is [\lambda_1=14.681970642123895.] The nonaxisymmetric extension introduces azimuthal mode number (m): [\mathcal L_m f =\frac1r\frac{d}{dr}\left(r\frac{df}{dr}\right)-\frac{m^2}{r^2}f.] Regular eigenfunctions are (J_m(kr)). Under the same radial Neumann condition, their positive wave numbers satisfy [J_m'(kR)=0.] These equations provide analytical reference solutions for the numerical verification campaigns. 2. Fundamental radial eigenmode verification Campaigns ZP-61V09–V17 investigated the cylindrical radial operator, boundary treatment, analytical reference values, eigenvalue extraction, and numerical precision. The verification process included correction of analytical-reference and eigensolver issues identified during earlier campaigns. The final independently computed eigenvalues demonstrated second-order spatial convergence. Radial cells Numerical eigenvalue Relative error 128 14.6808742753 7.467 × 10⁻⁵ 256 14.6816965449 1.867 × 10⁻⁵ 512 14.6819021175 4.667 × 10⁻⁶ Independent eigenpair residuals were reported at approximately (10^{-12})–(10^{-11}) over these resolutions. The high-resolution Rayleigh-quotient study extended to 8192 radial cells, reaching a reported relative eigenvalue error of (1.823\times10^{-8}). Result: Strong numerical evidence of second-order convergence for the fundamental nonconstant radial eigenvalue. 3. Higher radial eigenmode verification Campaigns ZP-61V20–V21 extended the analysis to four nonconstant radial modes. All four exhibited second-order convergence under radial grid refinement. Results at 512 radial cells Radial mode Relative eigenvalue error Observed order 1 4.667 × 10⁻⁶ 2.000 2 1.565 × 10⁻⁵ 2.000 3 3.290 × 10⁻⁵ 2.000 4 5.643 × 10⁻⁵ 2.000 Higher radial modes exhibit progressively larger discretization errors at fixed resolution, consistent with their shorter spatial wavelengths. Result: The tested numerical formulation reproduces multiple radial eigenvalues with the expected second-order accuracy. 4. Weighted orthogonality closure Campaign ZP-61V22 evaluated the discrete cylindrical weighted orthogonality condition: [U^\top WU\approx I,] where (U) contains numerical eigenvectors and (W) represents the cylindrical radial-volume weighting. Reported results Radial cells Maximum off-diagonal overlap Maximum diagonal error 256 1.142 × 10⁻¹⁵ 6.661 × 10⁻¹⁶ 512 1.248 × 10⁻¹⁵ 6.661 × 10⁻¹⁶ 1024 2.820 × 10⁻¹⁵ 1.776 × 10⁻¹⁵ These measurements are near double-precision floating-point accuracy. They resolve the previously observed discrepancy in the earlier orthogonality diagnostic, provided the same intended discrete eigenvectors and weights were used. Result: Weighted orthogonality and normalization verified to approximately FP64 precision for the tested eigenvectors. 5. Nonaxisymmetric azimuthal spectra Campaign ZP-61V24 expanded the spectral study to azimuthal families [m=0,1,2,3.] Four radial eigenvalues were reported for each family, producing 16 numerical eigenvalue comparisons in total. Lowest positive eigenvalue in each family Azimuthal mode Analytical wave number Numerical eigenvalue Relative error 0 3.831706 14.681697 1.867 × 10⁻⁵ 1 1.841184 3.389958 7.448 × 10⁻⁸ 2 3.054237 9.328365 1.808 × 10⁻⁷ 3 4.201189 17.649994 2.915 × 10⁻⁷ The largest reported relative error among the nonzero analytical eigenvalues in this campaign was approximately (1.597\times10^{-4}), or 0.01597%. The zero eigenvalue of the constant (m=0) Neumann mode is assessed using absolute rather than relative error. Result: Strong single-resolution agreement with the analytical nonaxisymmetric Bessel spectrum. Additional convergence and full-grid angular-discretization tests are required before claiming complete three-dimensional cylindrical verification. 6. Time-dependent wave verification Campaign ZP-61V18 evaluated the frequency of the fundamental cylindrical wave mode. The measured frequency errors decreased at approximately second order over radial resolutions from 64 to 512 cells. Campaigns ZP-61V19 and V19.1 subsequently investigated longer-time phase and energy behavior. Temporal refinement results — 20 periods Relative timestep Reported energy drift Phase error 1.00 1.494 × 10⁻³ 4.415 × 10⁻³ 0.50 7.478 × 10⁻⁴ 2.371 × 10⁻³ 0.25 3.743 × 10⁻⁴ 3.502 × 10⁻³ Energy drift decreased approximately linearly with timestep, indicating first-order convergence of the reported drift measure. The phase error did not converge monotonically. Result: Fundamental wave-frequency convergence was demonstrated, while the temporal-integrity audit remains open. 7. Verification campaign summary Campaign Primary investigation Outcome V09–V13 Radial residuals, boundary closure, eigenvalue extraction Numerical issues identified and corrected V14–V17 Rayleigh quotient and independent eigenpairs Second-order eigenvalue convergence V18 Time-dependent fundamental frequency Second-order frequency convergence V19–V19.1 Long-time energy and phase Partial; further investigation required V20 Higher radial eigenmodes Analytical agreement V21 Higher-mode grid convergence Second-order across four modes V22 Weighted orthogonality closure Approximately FP64 precision V24 Nonaxisymmetric azimuthal spectra Analytical agreement for (m=0,1,2,3) 8. Scope and scientific limitations This release verifies mathematical and numerical properties of reduced cylindrical spectral problems. It does not establish full nonlinear MHD accuracy, magnetic-force balance, Z-pinch equilibrium preservation, physical instability growth rates, or astrophysical plasma predictions. The nonaxisymmetric eigenvalue results require further documentation of the operator implementation and independent radial/azimuthal convergence tests. Long-time energy conservation and temporal phase accuracy also require additional verification. These limitations are explicitly retained to distinguish demonstrated numerical properties from future research objectives. 9. Future research The verified cylindrical eigenmode framework provides a foundation for subsequent numerical investigations involving: Full-grid nonaxisymmetric (m=1,2,3) verification. Angular periodicity and axis regularity. Multimode wave propagation and mode coupling. Analytical reconstruction of cylindrical current density and Lorentz forces. Pressure-balanced Z-pinch equilibria. Axisymmetric and nonaxisymmetric plasma perturbations. Density-dependent and magnetic-field-dependent stability analysis. The next planned research stage is the ALADIN ZP-62 — Cylindrical Z-Pinch (J\times B) Force-Balance Verificationcampaign. 10. Conclusion ALADIN Galactic Plasma Dynamics v0.7 documents a substantial numerical verification effort covering fundamental and higher radial Bessel eigenmodes, second-order spectral convergence, FP64-level weighted orthogonality, and nonaxisymmetric cylindrical eigenvalue families. The results provide a reproducible verification target for future cylindrical numerical solvers, subject to release of the corresponding source code, configuration, and benchmark data. The central achievement of v0.7 is the extension from a single verified radial eigenvalue to a multi-mode cylindrical spectral benchmark with clearly documented numerical accuracy and remaining limitations. Release status: Numerical spectral verification — documented benchmark results. Next stage: Cylindrical magnetic-force reconstruction and Z-pinch equilibrium testing.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233621176
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: