Work

The Twin Paradox

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This contribution presents a methodological analysis of the twin paradox based on the comparison of dynamical histories through a third independent ruler, calibrated in a common reference frame and comoving with neither of the two twins. The central proposal is to distinguish the reciprocal description of physical measurements within local reference frames from an external metrological comparison using an independent standard. This distinction neither rejects nor modifies Lorentz transformations or the standard predictions of special relativity. Rather, it examines the methodological role assigned to measuring instruments in comparing the histories of the two twin systems. The contribution distinguishes two complementary levels of analysis: Geometrical and relativistic description: the standard relativistic framework describes spacetime relations and allows the calculation of the proper time accumulated along each worldline. Dynamical reconstruction: the analysis of the complete physical histories makes it possible to identify how the two trajectories differ and to interpret the resulting asymmetry. A numerical benchmark illustrates the comparison. The document explicitly distinguishes the standard relations of special relativity from the proposed operational metric rule, associated with the third independent ruler protocol. The latter is presented as a hypothesis within the proposed theoretical framework, not as a result derived from special relativity. The contribution is accompanied by three technical supporting files: validazione_terzo_righello.py: numerical validation script. letture_terzo_righello.csv: reference readings and numerical data. esito_validazione.txt: recorded outcome of the validation checks. The supporting documents are provided in their original Italian form in order to preserve the integrity of the previously validated materials. The broader methodological point is that an apparent paradox should also prompt a critical examination of the assumptions, measurement procedures, and comparison criteria used to formulate it.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233621735
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: