Work

WHEN PETITIONING BECOMES "BAD FAITH": Institutional Efficiency, Reason-Giving and the Right to Address Public Authorities — A Latvian Supreme Court Case Study (2026)

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This independent legal research paper examines the relationship between the right to petition public authorities, institutional efficiency, administrative accountability, and the prohibition of abusive or bad-faith submissions in Latvia. The study is based on documented correspondence involving the Supreme Court of Latvia and the Secretariat of the Judicial Council during 2026, with particular attention to the Supreme Court's letter of 16 November 2026 (No. 10-1/11-1320nos). In that letter, the institution referred to 30 submissions received during 2026 and expressed the view that the applicant's exercise of the right to submit petitions demonstrated bad faith and adversely affected institutional efficiency. The central legal question is whether the number, frequency, or repetition of submissions can justify such an assessment without an individualized examination of their content, purpose, factual basis, and relationship to previous institutional responses. The analysis considers Article 104 and Article 92 of the Constitution of Latvia, Section 7(1)(7) of the Latvian Law on Submissions, relevant principles of European human rights law, and the distinction between administrative correspondence and procedural documents in judicial proceedings. The paper also examines the legitimate interest of public institutions in preventing abusive correspondence, while emphasizing the importance of proportionality, transparent reasoning, institutional competence, and effective access to legal remedies. Particular attention is given to distinguishing repetitive submissions from new evidence, requests for clarification, independent legal research communicated for information, and submissions requiring a separate procedural assessment. The publication does not assert that judicial misconduct or a human rights violation has been conclusively established. It identifies legal questions and evidentiary requirements for independent assessment. Research type: Independent legal analysis and documented case study. Research period: July–November 2026. Jurisdiction: Latvia. Keywords: Right to petition; bad-faith submissions; access to justice; Supreme Court of Latvia; institutional accountability; administrative efficiency; judicial administration; reason-giving; proportionality; rule of law; effective remedies.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233733279
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10