PRIMITIVE PRESERVATION AND SELECTION OF COHERENCE From Conservation Algebra to Physical Interaction
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper opens a foundational investigation into whether primitive coherence, continuity, and relational composition can determine a physical constitutive law without presupposing a gauge group, interaction potential, or observed mass. The first test distinguishes conservation constraints from dynamical selection. A connected triangular flow network has one independent conserved circulation even after external sources are fixed. Positive, local, reversal-symmetric, strictly convex quadratic and quartic costs assign different stationary circulation values while respecting the same conservation law and network symmetries. A power-law family generalizes the counterexample, and a mixed quadratic–quartic cost shows that even imposing linear response near equilibrium does not fix nonlinear behavior. Exact global linear affinity selects a quadratic potential only when adopted as an additional constitutive assumption. The results establish a conditional no-go theorem: conservation, locality, symmetry, convexity, and minimization do not uniquely select physical interaction. The paper ends with explicit proof obligations for primitive constitutive selection and observation-first empirical discrimination. Keywords: primitive coherence; constitutive selection; conservation algebra; reclosure; network flow; nonlinear response; mathematical no-go; falsification.
Author: Lilien, Philip
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233797765
