Work

Creditworthy Rejects: A Pre-registered Fair-Access Study of a Credit Scorecard, a Thin-File Model, and a Second-Look Policy That Failed Its Own Test

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A credit cut-off does not only refuse people who would have defaulted. At any stated risk appetite it also refuses a measurable number of applicants who, in the event, repaid. This study counts them, prices the alternatives, and then tests a remedy against a pre-registered pass line it fails. On the UCI credit card portfolio (Taiwan, 2005; 30,000 accounts; held-out test set of 9,000), a gradient boosting scorecard (AUC 0.7810, 95 percent bootstrap CI 0.7693 to 0.7919) is cut at the point where the approved book's observed default rate equals the portfolio's performing-book rate of 12.00 percent. At that cut-off (PD 0.2293; 6,375 approved, 2,625 rejected), 1,399 of the 2,625 rejected applicants (53.3 percent, CI 48.2 to 77.6 percent) did not default: the creditworthy rejects. A model restricted to behavioural features, the thin-file situation of a newcomer with no bureau history, scores AUC 0.7687 against the full model's 0.7810, a gap of 0.0123 that confirms the pre-registered hypothesis that behavioural evidence alone carries most of the signal. A fairness audit at the same cut-off finds approval-rate gaps of 3.6 points by sex, 12.6 by age band, and 29.2 by education, with group sizes printed beside every rate. The proposed remedy, a Second-Look Recovery Policy that re-scores rejects with the thin-file model and approves those whose behavioural PD matches the typical approved applicant's, was pre-registered to recover at least 15 percent of creditworthy rejects at a cost of at most 1.00 percentage point of book default rate. It recovered 1.2 percent (17 of 1,399) at a cost of 0.02 points, and is therefore REFUTED on its recovery bound: the strict band is nearly empty because the two models' scores are correlated. The method transports to a second population (UCI Statlog German Credit: logistic regression AUC 0.8022, gradient boosting 0.7848, on 300 test accounts with wide intervals). The contribution is the accounting discipline: every claim in this paper was registered before it was run, every interval prices its whole procedure, and the failed remedy is reported as the finding.
Language: English
Subfield: Accounting
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233813819
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10