Work

Functional Carrier Substitution Between Levels of Organization: Recursive Matryoshka of Functional Possibilities (Research Project Passport)

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This research project passport establishes a conceptual and methodological framework for analyzing transitions between levels of organizational complexity in terms of functional possibility spaces rather than evolutionary fitness alone. Working Hypothesis (Functional Carrier Substitution): During a transition between levels of organization, constraints on the autonomous degrees of freedom of lower-level components (F_local ↓) do not represent a mere loss of function. Instead, under high functional integration (I ↑) and specific structural generative conditions (C), functions cease to be properties of autonomous components and are transferred to—and transformed by—the organized whole as a new functional carrier (F_global ↑), forming a recursive sequence of levels: T_n(E_n) = S_n ≡ E_{n+1}. Key Methodological Elements:1. Distinction from Evolutionary Transitions in Individuality (ETI): While classical ETI models (Maynard Smith & Szathmáry, Michod) describe recursive transitions in the currency of fitness, this framework tracks the reorganization of functional possibility spaces.2. Diagnostic Counterexample: A crystal demonstrates that local constraint and high physical integration alone are insufficient to generate a new functional carrier (F_local ↓ ∧ I ↑ ⇏ F_global ↑), isolating the central open research question: identifying the structural condition C that turns compressing constraints into generative ones.3. Empirical Anchor Points & Falsifiability: The hypothesis is anchored against empirical observations in developmental biology and transcriptomics (Dictyostelium discoideum, Volvox, signaling entropy SCENT, CytoTRACE) and equipped with explicit falsifiability criteria and scientific limitations. Status: Conceptual working passport (frozen pending further structural classification and formalization).
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233825661
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10