Beyond Document Relevance: Evaluating Citation-Set Structure in Citation Recommendation
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: When authors of a scientific paper cite several papers at a single point, they are often not aiming to cite the exact same claim repeatedly. Citation sets include a high degree of author judgement — they are often chosen together to cover a conceptual space, reference both a problem and its main methods, or pair a method with a result it is usually compared to. Despite this, citation recommendation, as it is usually posed, ignores this set-level structure, and instead scores each target in isolation to maximize its independent semantic similarity to the citing sentence. We show that in the case of recommending a citation set, this may be the wrong approach. We introduce LOCUS, a controlled evaluation that determines whether or not a retriever can tell which of a paper’s own citations belong at one sentence rather than another one in the text, and that looks beyond the use of topic-level similarity. A simple, training-free co-citation reranker built from past citation structure improves Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR) by +0.104 to +0.124 across four retrievers. The gain largely comes from 61.3% of cases where the candidate and an already-known citation are linked in the citation graph, while using citations from other locations in the same paper hurts performance. In corpus-wide retrieval with a self-retrieved first citation, SPECTER2 still improves Recall@20 by +0.075. Further, once one citation is known, the retriever is 2.6× more effective at recovering the remaining members at Recall@1.
Source: Valency Hub
DOI: 10.83295/hh2e-9r2x
Language: English
Subfield: Information Systems
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233844351
