From Possibility to Probability: Population-Genetic Accessibility of Enzyme Specialization After Gene Duplication Original Article
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Promiscuous enzymes catalyze more than one reaction, creating opportunities for new functions but also trade-offs when improving one reaction reduces another. Gene duplication may resolve this conflict by allowing the two copies to specialize, but only if the new copy survives long enough to diverge. We combined a constraint-based model of enzyme activity with forward-time simulations in SLiM to separate what happens after a duplicate is retained from whether a new duplicate can reach that state. Under dosage compensation, persistent specialization evolved in 56 of 300 populations in which duplication was imposed, but in none of 5,700 simulations that began with one new duplicate. Including additive dosage increased establishment from 51 to 2,421 of 5,700 origins, increased near-fixation from 1 to 2,421, and produced 102 persistent specialists. However, dosage did not change specialization after population-wide retention: 61 of 1,140 compensated populations and 60 of 1,140 additive populations specialized. Once every individual carried the duplicate, the shared dosage benefit no longer changed which genotypes were favored. All specialists arising from a single origin occurred under strong catalytic antagonism and high mutation supply. Thus, dosage primarily determined whether a new duplicate survived and spread, whereas catalytic conflict and mutation supply determined whether retained copies later specialized.
Source: Research Square
Author: Jordan A. Dowell
Institution: Louisiana State University
Language: English
Subfield: Genetics
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Louisiana State University
OpenAlex ID: W7233912764
