Work

Different assembly and binning strategies recover contrasting genome catalogues and community profiles

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: In genome-resolved metagenomics, different assembly and binning strategies can be employed to reconstruct microbial genomes and community profiles. We used metagenomic data from a longitudinal experiment, in which mice were exposed to a series of environmental stressors, to compare four approaches: single-coverage, multi-coverage, co-assembly, and multi-split. We evaluated their effectiveness in reconstructing microbial genomes, determining their relative abundances, and analysing functional profiles while accounting for computational efficiency. Our findings indicate significant differences in the quantity and quality of recovered genomes across strategies, which in turn influenced community profiles and research outcomes related to microbiota resilience to environmental pressures and functional differences between exposure to contrasting temperatures. We conclude that the choice of assembly and binning strategies is crucial and needs to be thoroughly assessed considering available resources, study design, and research aims, as the strategy employed for data processing can significantly affect the results and conclusions of metagenomic studies. Importance Metagenomic sequencing allows researchers to reconstruct the genomes of the microbes living in an environment and to measure how abundant each one is. Before this can be done, the sequencing data must be assembled and grouped using one of several possible strategies, and the choice is often driven by habit or computational convenience. Using faecal samples from mice exposed to heat and cold, we show that ten strategies yield markedly different genome collections, community profiles, and even statistical conclusions about how gut microbiomes respond to environmental stress, while differing several-fold in computational cost. No single strategy performed best on all criteria. Our results offer quantitative guidance for choosing data-processing strategies that fit a study’s design, aims, and resources, and they warn that conclusions from metagenomic studies can depend on this often overlooked decision.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233920236
Cites: 53
Cited by:
Related to: 10