Negligence of Mining Corporations in Resolving Community Land Rights: A Tort Law Perspective
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study aims to analyze the fulfillment of the elements of unlawful act by a mining company against the community's land rights in a village in Mamuju Regency, as well as to examine the legal settlement efforts that have been undertaken. The study employs an empirical juridical approach with a qualitative analytical method, through interviews with affected community members, village officials, relevant government agencies, legal practitioners, and the company, complemented by literature review. The novelty of this study lies in its focus on the fulfillment of the five cumulative elements of unlawful act based on empirical facts in the field, rather than solely on the legality of the mining business license as commonly examined in previous studies. The findings show that all five elements of unlawful act are cumulatively fulfilled, ranging from concrete actions such as document collection and land staking without resolving land rights, the unlawful nature of the conduct due to violation of community civil rights, continuing negligence in realizing written commitments, material and immaterial losses, to a coherent causal link between the actions and the losses incurred. The legal settlement efforts undertaken progressed in stages, from socialization, reporting, formal mediation, to a formal warning letter, yet have not resulted in a complete resolution due to weak enforcement of the agreements reached. This study concludes that the company's actions indicate an unlawful act, and that the main obstacle to dispute resolution lies in the enforcement mechanism of agreements rather than the absence of a deliberation forum.
Source: ADVANCED PRIVATE LEGAL INSIGHTS
DOI: 10.56087/5wjg4k85
Institution: Universitas Muslim Indonesia
Language: English
Topic: Legal Studies and Policies
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7233942412
