Work

The Right to Have Rights as a Legal Test for the Rohingya in Bangladesh

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Hannah Arendt described the condition of the stateless as the loss of a “right to have rights”; the right to belong to a community in which one’s actions and opinions count. This article turns that idea into a legal test and applies it to the Rohingya in Bangladesh. The test has three cumulative thresholds: recognition (being legible to the legal order as a person), standing (being able to bring a claim and have it heard) and agency (being able to act with legal effect). Each threshold is assessed at three levels: what the law says, whether a person can use it, and whether using it changes the outcome. Drawing on doctrinal and documentary analysis of the Constitution, statutes, case law and camp instruments, the article finds that the Rohingya are recognised but unheard. Registration makes them administratively legible but confers no civil legal personality; they appear before the legal system mainly as accused persons rather than as claimants; and their movement, work, association and expression are restricted by executive and camp-level measures. These failures flow not from any statute that denies their rights, but from sub-statutory instruments of doubtful legality under article 31 of the Constitution. The Constitution’s text grounds standing for “any person” in respect of core personal rights, but it cannot by itself restore agency, and standing on paper has not become standing in practice. The article offers a constitutional test of rightlessness that can be applied to stateless populations in other states outside the Refugee Convention.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7233963192
FWCI:
Cites: 21
Cited by:
Related to: 10